Was Mick McCarthy Right?
Last night, Mick McCarthy came to United and fielded a completely under-strength side. Of the eleven that started against Tottenham at the weekend, only the goalkeeper remained the same.
Wolves play Burnley on Sunday and Mick McCarthy’s thinking seemed to be, “Well, it doesn’t matter who I put out against Manchester United, we are going to lose the game anyway so I might as well rest my ‘proper’ team for the far more winnable game against Burnley”.
Thoroughly understandable, I suppose, but Premier League rules do state that “In every League Match each participating Club shall field a full strength team“.
We all know that this doesn’t always happen and in these days of squad rotation, it isn’t always easy to say what exactly is a club’s “full strength team”.
It was probably Fergie who started all of this squad rotation mallarky but the difference when Fergie does it is that he still puts out a team that he fully expects to win the game.
With the team Mick McCarthy put out last night, there was absolutely no chance of them beating Manchester United at Old Trafford and the 3-0 scoreline could have been a lot worse had United taken full advantage of their chances and possession.
For the 2,400 travelling Wolves fans who had paid around £40 each to watch “their team”, you can only have sympathy. They shouldn’t have bothered because their manager certainly didn’t.
My main concern about this is that it could start a trend amongst the “lesser” clubs in the division.
The integrity of the league demands that every team gives 100% in every game and puts out the best team that they possibly can.
If the lower clubs start to effectively “throw” the matches against the top teams and decide that the best thing to do is just battle it out amongst themselves in their own “mini-league” then it just makes a farce of the whole thing.
I am also quite sure that anyone connected with Chelsea last night were absolutely fuming that Mick McCarthy basically handed us the three points.
As for his players, one of the things about achieving promotion from the Championship to the Premier League is that even if you are eventually relegated, you do at least get to pit yourselves against the Manchester Uniteds of this world, to play in the biggest stadiums in the country in front of the biggest crowds. He denied his players that opportunity last night.
I suppose we now have to wait and see if Wolves do actually beat Burnley at the weekend and, in the longer term, avoid relegation. If Mick McCarthy achieves both of those outcomes then we probably have to say “fair enough” but if he doesn’t then I hope he regrets last night (and any other times he might do it between now and the end of the season) because he will have cheated his players, his fans and the Premier League as a whole.
Over to you Mick.






Let’s face it: How many ‘stars’ does Wolves has?? 3 or 4??
Kightly and Keogh are injured. The other ‘star’ players which are Craddock, Doyle, Milijas, etc.. have all played 2 successive matches against Tottenham and Bolton and they have won both of them. So the ‘star’ players need some rest before an important match against Burnley.
All teams do rotation…So, McCarthy did it too. SAF did it in the Champions League against Wolfsburg. We can’t blame McCarthy for doing this, because his aim is to stay in the Premier League, not to beat the big teams
Hi Red,
I know exactly why McCarthy did what he did, the question is: was he right to do it?.
When Fergie rotates his squad, he changes maybe 3-4 players but tries to mix a blend of youth and experience but whatever he does, he does NOT put out a team just for the sake of making up the numbers, he still expects his team to win.
This wasn’t squad rotation, it was Mick McCarthy saying, “We have no chance of winning this game, no matter who I play, so I might as well play players who won’t be missed too much should they get injured”.
As for the players needing a rest, Kightly and Keogh are both 23. He’s treating them like they are 33.
Maybe as you say, his aim is not to beat the big teams but it sure as hell is his job to give them a game – what’s the point of playing in the Premier League if you don’t actually want to play against the best teams?
Yes, I know: Money, money, money.
I’ve been reading quite a lot on Wolves’ fans discussion boards since writing this article and the general feeling amongst them seems to be 60/40 against what McCarthy did which is about where I stand on it. I can see why he did it, I understand completely, it just doesn’t quite seem to be in the spirit of the competition and as I say, if other teams start to follow suit, it would be very damaging for the integrity of the Premier League.
Dress it up how you want but McCarthy threw this game. As a United supporter, I suppose I shouldn’t be whining about it but if we win the league, I want it to be on merit and not because teams come to Old Trafford with no intention of giving us a game.
If you consider the pressure under which the managers thrive, McCarthy was only trying to reach the objective set by his Board: stay in the Premier League. Therefore the Burnley match is very important for them. And yeah, maybe McCarthy knew his best team would not be able to compete, so why bother tiring them just before a capital match?
I don’t care what team they field as long as WE play in a professional and mature way without being over confident.
Kightly and Keogh are truly injured. Both have ankle injuries.
It’s a highly contentious issue and even now, the Wolves fans are divided in their opinion and so am I to a large extent.
You’re right to say that so long as WE do our job, what other teams do is not really our concern. At the start of a season, every team has 38 games ahead of them so in that regard, everything is in the hands of every team. You win all your games, you win the League, no matter what anyone else does.
On this occasion, we were the beneficiaries of Mick McCarthy’s Christmas Gift but what goes around comes around and if the lower teams all started to field second string sides everytime they played Chelsea, how would you feel?